The satellite and mobile industries have long played in their own field, rarely intersecting despite being complementary. The disconnect between the two camps is surprisingly large. Neither side paying much attention to developments on the other side. Their relationship even turned adversarial where spectrum rights were at stake. Both industries are now trying to work together by defining complementary services. However, beneath these attempts remains long-standing misconceptions. We recently undertook a study exploring the prospects of mobile-satellite intersect. This is the first of two articles to provide context. [See here for the second article.]
Continue reading5G Deployment Trends and Prospects
Research from Xona Partners on 5G deployment trends and prospects reveals that operators will focus on mid-band spectrum. The millimeter wave technology will remain a niche play in the short and medium terms.
5G is a Mid-Band Play
Operators around the world have spent over $16.2 Billion acquiring 3.5 GHz spectrum (C-band) in the 18 months between January 2018 – June 2019. Deployment in the major Asian markets will center on 3.x GHz where regulators in Korea and China released substantial amounts.
Continue reading5G Spectrum Valuation Benchmarks
How much is 5G spectrum worth? Xona Partners published two reports on recent 5G spectrum auction valuation benchmarks. The first is a report on international mid-band spectrum auctions in the 3 – 5 GHz band. The second is a report on millimeter wave spectrum auctions in the 24 – 42 GHz bands. Both reports provide details of the price paid by service providers in 5G spectrum auctions around the world. The reports also provide detailed information on spectrum holdings by mobile network operators. The midband spectrum report includes a section to guide bidders plan their strategy and budget for the Canadian C-Band 5G spectrum auction scheduled for June 2021. Click here for brochures. Contact me for additional details and for CBRS spectrum valuation services.
The LEO Satellites Threat: Impact on Incumbents
I highlighted in my previous article on LEO satellites the capacity that will come online within the next few years. In 2024, the capacity supply from LEO satellites could be 24x of what GEO satellites offer today. Such a rapid increase in capacity over a short period of 5 years could have great consequences on many telecom incumbents. Here, I highlight the LEO satellites threat to three telecom segments that could face sever consequences.
Continue readingLEO Satellites and The Consequences to The Space Race.
A new kind of space race is on. If all goes according to plans, a few thousand satellites will be orbiting the earth to provide internet connectivity from space. These are a new generation of high-capacity satellites that will orbit at relatively low altitudes to provide unprecedented performance from space-based networks. These low-earth orbit (LEO) satellites will be circling between 500 and 2,000 km above the earth surface and reduce signal delay by over 5 times from geostationary satellites (sub 100 msec vs. 500 msec). LEO satellites promise to have far-reaching consequences on the established ecosystems.
Continue readingOverview of US Auction 102 24 GHz Results
Auction 102 concluded on May 28th raising $2 Billion for 2904 licenses for 700 MHz in 24 GHz (24.25–24.45; 24.75–25.25 GHz). [FCC]
AT&T and T-Mobile spent $982 million and $803 million for 831 and 1346 licenses, respectively.
Continue readingThe Skyrocketing C-Band Valuation
The FCC concluded Auction 102 netting over $2 billion for over 2,900 licenses in the 24/25 GHz band. A good milestone, but more critical is the availability of 3.5 GHz spectrum which has better performance tradeoffs than millimeter wave spectrum. With all the talk about the ‘5G race’, availability of mid-band spectrum makes the most difference on who will benefit from 5G. The US continues to lag in mid-band availability awaiting the maturity of the CBRS band. In the meantime, global C-band valuation is skyrocketing.
Continue readingFive Hot Technologies To Watch!
by Dr. Riad Hartani, Xona Partners
Internet Intersects Space Technologies
The space race is on again! This time the focus is on building a new generation of low earth orbit satellite constellations to deliver broadband internet. A simple equation lies at its heart: Internet to more people around the world; to keep the business model for the cloud/internet players going. Breakthrough in space technologies has led to a drastic reduction in the cost of building, launching and operating satellites. We have been actively working on the latest designs bringing in Internet knowhow into the new generation of satellite technologies.
Continue readingA View on Private Networks in Mining and Oil & Gas
Safety. Productivity. Reliability. These are the three axioms that govern the mining and oil & gas industries. I have been researching the potential for private networks in these verticals to determine what role, if any, could LTE and 5G networks play. Looking back over the past 10+ years, private networks held much promise, but showed little success. Will the future be different? 4G/5G private networks have to answer to these axioms for any chance at market traction.
Continue readingWireless Technology Migration: Drivers and Lessons Learned
While 5G attracts most attention, operators had been making decisions on how to retire legacy 2G and 3G networks to free up spectrum for LTE networks and support higher capacity. Unlike earlier technology migrations where the path was clear, operators have to make tough decisions on which network to turn off first: 2G or 3G. In this, we find that operators are highly pragmatic focusing on revenue and service maximization. Understanding the practical implications sheds light on how the future could unfold.
Continue readingState of the Telco Industry: MWC2019 Perspectives
This year I’ll opt to write a few quick thoughts on the state of the telco industry instead of the annual report that follows MWC. Time is tight, so let’s get straight to the main points.
Foldable Phones
Foldable phones were the main highlight of MWC2019. Both Samsung and Huawei launched models featuring foldable screens. At prices in the range of €2,300, these phones will be the ultimate status symbols. You can’t expect high volumes with this kind of pricing. If the industry is looking for a device that will make the business case for 5G, I don’t think it will be these phones.
Continue readingEdge Computing Economics: Is Latency Worth the Price?
The benefits of edge computing, low latency and backhaul efficiency are well understood. However, there is a cost to realize these benefits through small data centers. Hyperscale data centers are the backbone of the cloud. The cost structure and operation of these data centers is well understood. On the other hand, different requirements govern the edge cloud leading to different economics. Understanding these economics and monetization potential is fundamental to evaluating the business case for edge computing. The question becomes: is latency worth the cost of edge computing? Continue reading
Are Wireless Private Networks the Next Frontier?
Two paths to 5G deployments are emerging: consumer and enterprise deployments. The former is how operators make the vast majority of their revenue. The latter is receiving much interest as it promises a new bump in revenue. Enterprise private networks is not a new idea: it has been slow to realize it because of economics among other factors. New technologies promise to reduce the cost structure. Some equipment vendors, like Nokia, are making a bet on private networks. Operators in their turn are looking to play a role in the enterprise market as the consumer segment reached saturation.
In my view, making a bet on the enterprise segment requires new operating models that the mobile ecosystem has been slow at evolving. Moreover, 5G is not a prerequisite to success in this space: it’s not evident that enterprises are ready to benefit from the advantages that 5G provide. Additionally, competing technologies exist. It may be that applications in vertical markets will take time to mature by which time the 5G ecosystem would be ready. However, this only serves to increase the market risk. Continue reading
Can Edge Computing Help Telcos Win in a Cloud Play?
Edge computing presents a new opportunity for telecom service providers to have a cloud play. Their proximity to users gives them an inherent advantage at the ‘edge.’ The question is: are the telcos ready to capitalize on this opportunity? What could be their approach in securing their share of this market? And, will they succeed in claiming their share of this emerging market?
The rise of the edge computing
Ever since the early age of computers, there’s a constant battle between centralized architectures represented by mainframe computers and servers and the edge represented by personal computers and mobile devices. The mobile cloud has proved extremely successful in meeting today’s applications’ requirements. But the explosion in number of devices driven by IoT and other applications is putting pressure to distribute cloud services towards the edge. New applications with stringent performance requirements necessitate processing closer to the user and device. This made edge computing one of the hottest topics of discussions in industry circles. Continue reading
Is China Really Leading the 5G Race?
It is fashionable to talk about the race to 5G. This theme started last year, and has picked up this year with many opinion articles published on the topic. Perhaps the one that got most attention is the white paper by Deloitte: The chance to lead for a decade. The paper compared US networks and investments to that of other countries, with a focus on China. Of the several comparisons made, one in particular got me thinking: can we use the number of cell sites to qualify who’s winning or losing a race? Never mind whether or not the whole notion of a 5G race is relevant (I’ll save this for another post), but is the number of sites, which is a proxy to coverage and capacity indicators, a legitimate metric? In this, I don’t mean to pick on one element of the argument. This question is more fundamental: should coverage and capacity remain the sole indicators for wireless services?
China ahead on number of sites – and that’s that!
According to the Deloitte, China has 14.1 sites per 10,000 people vs. the US’ 4.7 (3x). Alternatively, China has 5.3 sites/square miles vs. the US’ 0.4 (13x). At face value, this is a big disparity, but one that’s well known. The larger of the US carriers like AT&T and Verizon have on the order of 60,000 cell sites, each. That pales in comparison with China Mobile’s 500,000+ LTE sites alone! Continue reading